Smile 2
Writer
& Director – Parker Finn
2024,
USA
Stars
~ Naomi Scott, Rosemarie DeWitt, Lukas Gage
Parker
Finn’s franchise ‘Smile’ is proving to be quite the empathic franchise.
Whether you see its premise of psychological illness as an infectious demon as
questionable or as a manifestation of an old misconception, there is no
doubting that Naomi Scott’s performance has the fiercest compassion. Just
recently, I heard some work colleagues opine that as a celebrity had been into
drugs and whatever, their untimely death was somehow unsympathetic, and
obviously this lacks nuance, consideration and kindness. As Skye Riley, Naomi
Scott’s raw turn as a successful pop star who is filled with self-loathing –
and therefore most susceptible to the smile demon – never once drops the ball
into implying she is deserving, even at her worst. The film goes a long way to
determining that the celebrity life isolates and brings out the worst in an
individual. It is Scott’s performance that is central and elevates the sequel
to higher merit, even as it contains several showstoppers.
There’s more confidence here with the bigger budget and a deliberate
focus that the original. It comes with many memorable images: a traffic
accident blood smear like a smile; and the relentlessly smiling fangirl at the
signing; a face pulled into a distorted grin in a vanity mirror, to name just three.
The opening scene had me engaged in a way that ‘Terrifier 3’ didn’t
manage at all – a carefully choreographed long take will always grab my
attention – and by the end I was wondering why so many were saying they hadn’t
seen something along the lines of ‘The Substance’ ever before. It won’t
top ‘The Substance’ but then ‘Smile 2’ has a more eloquent agenda
and characters and is more a bowl of multi-coloured candy than day-glo jelly. MikeMcGranaghan finds ‘Smile 2’s last act laughable, but as I was reading it
as viewing the mental collapse of a flawed character, as well as the contagion potentially
spreading, I was left strangely moved.
‘Smile
2’ spins through small-time
crookery, popstar biopic, music video and supernatural curse so that the jump
scares aren’t just cheap tactics (one jump scare had the entire audience I was
with vibrating with chuckles at being caught for thirty seconds afterwards). And
of course, the world of fame is the domain of fake smiles, although arguably
Finn doesn’t quite make the most of this. Where he does is with the creepiness
of an approaching dance routine, where the audience is the prey.
Going
from the grey hues of the opening to the candy pop colourscheme of an endlessly
superficial pop-world to more nightmarish shadows of horror, Finn uses the
unique ability of cinema to undermine reality until everything collapses in on
itself. When the biggest enemy is your own self-hatred, there is little
reprieve and no winning.
All to
say ‘Smile 2’ is a fun downer, a A24 horror version of Brady Cobert’s ‘VoxLux’
with a foot in James Wan jump scares. But like it’s predecessor, there’s a
properly tragic feel and a haunting aftertaste and that most troubling and that
most underrated ingredient that makes up horror: unfairness.